Home History Blogs Portfolio FAQ Contact Terms Of Use
 
2008  2009  2010  2011  2012  2013  2014  2015  2016  2017
2018  2019  2020  2021  2022  2023  2024  2025  2026  2027
2028  2029  2030  2031  2032  2033  2034  2035  2036  2037
 
 
 
2016-2017 Offseason: Romo Leaving NFL For CBS
 
April 4th, 2017 At 7:41 PM CST
By Eric M. Scharf
 
Tony Romo – 13-year NFL star and former starting quarterback of “America’s Team” – has decided pro football he will quit, preceding the Dallas Cowboys’ decision to trigger the contractual split.

Before going further, “The Tortured Cowboys Fan” offers a prior write-up that postulated how this might build-up: "Head-On Collision With A Career Decision." Otherwise, The Tortured Cowboys Fan encourages you to continue with this historical menu.

The well-chronicled start to Romo’s end began with a preseason back injury against the Seattle Seahawks in 2016, preceded by a season-ending foot injury to then-backup QB Kellen Moore that left the Cowboys’ key on-field leadership position incredibly lean. Then-rookie fourth round draft pick, Dak Prescott, was elevated in an instant from third string to the starting spot.

Dallas tried in vain to procure another capable veteran to help Prescott settle in. The Cowboys would sign journeyman Mark Sanchez, testing fate, making (some) fans irate, and bordering on outright sin. Following Romo’s brief-but-successful game 16 appearance (undoubtedly performing a one-sided, seed-planting trade bait dance), the Cowboys left a Romo-produced lead to Sanchez, who would go onto foil it, flushing an almost certain franchise record 14th regular season victory – even with the second string reasonably doing their thing – right down the garbage time toilet. But then Sanchez – much like Kellen Moore – ultimately (and somewhat unbelievably) proved his value for Prescott as a junior QB coach or sideline mentor.

Tony Romo would never reach the field again, as he returned to his still-warm, season-long spot in the Cowboys’ QB bullpen.

The Dallas Cowboys, their fans, and prognosticators everywhere were ultimately treated by Dak to a quite unexpected and certainly unbelievable season-long, playoff-worthy 13-3 performance. Far from an understatement, everyone (from passionate sports debaters to absolute myopic haters) remembers how the promise of the 2014 Cowboys crumbled in 2015 like Tony Romo’s collar bone. Brandon Weeden, Matt Cassel, and Kellen Moore collectively (to varying degrees) caused Cowboys Nation to moan and groan, as they failed to deliver loss column abatement. While the Prescott-led Cowboys came up short – in a home playoff contest against the Green Bay Packers – Dak’s future looked (and looks) quite promising in the most popular American sport.

After an unconfirmed number of trade attempts to send Romo to one of at least two other playoff-ready teams (in the Denver Broncos and the Houston Texans) with which he preferred to end his career if forced, the Cowboys made the painful-but-necessary decision with Tony to get divorced.

 
 
Everyone – from prognosticators to Cowboys Nation – knew the (quality) quarterback-needy Broncos and Texans were more apt to patiently wait until Romo was granted a permanent vacation before making any attempt to formulate a transaction. While the Texans allegedly might have been willing to sacrifice a late-round pick, trading for a very capable yet increasingly infirm 37-year-old quarterback was something the Broncos publicly dismissed, no matter how much they might have been intrigued by another Peyton Manning-like tryst.

John Elway has as much of an ego as any former-star-player-turned-front-office-executive in the NFL and – for as limited as Trevor Siemian seemed and as (naturally) inexperienced as Paxton Lynch looked last year – Elway remains not averse to standing firm and seeing if either of his currently underwhelming options at QB could improve and consistently do well. A piece of Elway’s draft day reputation – however compartmentalized or small – arguably hinges on Lynch eventually succeeding and standing all 6’ 7” tall. Though – speaking of height – Elway’s participation in drafting the equally monstrous (but far less mobile and potentially less capable) Brock Osweiler just might fill some Denver fans with Broncos brain trust fright.

 
 
The Houston Texans – according to practically every source – were determined to draft ‘a’ quarterback of the future regardless of their pursuit of Romo, as an alternative needed to be in place (in the event of another Texans QB mental or physical tragedy) to avoid complete and total buyer’s remorse.

At the end of the day (regardless of the potential direction in which would-be Romo trade partners would sway), Dak Prescott’s consistent top-shelf play (on top of his uncommon year-one maturity) – more so than Romo’s most recent injury or his increasing fragility – made the Cowboys’ decision relatively easy.

While Romo was at the top of the list of QBs who could save their team's fat from the last-minute fire – in games over the past decade – he would ditch a chance to parlay his fresh release (to help another imperfect team reach the big dance) in favor of becoming a different kind of new hire, while letting his on-field career fade.

 
 
Tony Romo – once the dust settled – had a different televised football opportunity into which he was invited to steer, which should be a good distraction from sitting around wondering who meddled (with a possible chance to extend his playing career). After all – and as close as Romo and Jerry Jones had become (to regularly beating each other’s righteous drum) – Tony is only human and had to be mildly curious to learn if Jerry was still being a man of his word (in promising to release Romo to fly free as a bird) . . . or if Jerry really had the gall (to refuse all but the very best trade offers, thus, delaying or ruining Tony’s chances of ever receiving another team’s call).

Did Tony – in early March of this year – bid Cowboys Nation too soon a fond farewell, intimating his imminent freedom to offer his quarterbacking services to other organizations around the NFL?

Did Tony’s innocent Instagram broadcast undercut Jerry’s trade value desire and start a little delayed action fire? Depending upon whom you ask, Jerry was (and remains) the tip of the spear who said he would “do right by Tony,” so maybe in hindsight Jerry (the phony?) might be taken to task.

Perhaps it is as Bill “The Big Tuna” Parcells is always fond of saying: “It is what it is,” as the delay to Tony’s “promised” release gave him the right amount of time to reflect upon the career decision that was ultimately his.

 
 
Romo preempted the Cowboys’ decision to part ways with their former starting QB with the announcement of his new gig as lead NFL color analyst for CBS Sports on TV. (Strong) Rumor has it CBS settled on Romo (to replace a now-bewildered, former lead Phil Simms) after Peyton Manning repeatedly refused their most aggressive money-offering whims.

While the acronym will change (from NFL to CBS), Romo sounds ready and determined to show his performance range, and whether or not he truly has a flair for being part of a two-player team on-air will be anyone’s guess.

Danny White Disorder

As to how fans will choose to remember, Romo’s game day legacy will either be as an overachieving, undrafted free agent or a prematurely burnt / underachieving ember.

The Tortured Cowboys Fan (who – mind you – simply CANNOT STAND the schism of "Whataboutism") thinks Romo suffered from history-heaped and fan-forced “Danny White Disorder.” Danny – for those too young to remember – accomplished quite a Pro Bowl bit (while navigating a shallower injury pit), but he came up short when it was his (otherwise healthy) turn to personally push Dallas over the Super Bowl border.

 
 
Danny was a member of the Cowboys team that beat the Denver Broncos in Super Bowl XII. Danny was a member of the Cowboys team that lost to the Pittsburgh Steelers in Super Bowl XIII (because of an end zone catch someone failed to make clean). The fella' playing quarterback in those games, however, was the expectation-setting 12, not the shadow-fighting 11 (whom a healthy and available Roger Staubach would always shelve). While White did get in a few passes in XII, his one-sided job as a two-way player was to punt, not (yet) lead the offensive hunt.

White was 5-5 while leading in playoff contests but – when it came time to push the Cowboys over three consecutive conference championship humps – his late game hand-eye coordination would seemingly take a dump with untimely skill-betraying protests. White was haunted by an untimely one-second delay, between his truly brilliant offensive mind and his body’s execution of the drawn-up play. While it was not Danny who slipped on an impossible defensive banana chasing down Dwight Clark and Joe Montana, White's comeback-killing fumble – following a sack on the next offensive series – just encouraged irate fan flurries.

It did not matter that Romo was a smaller college, undrafted free agent who blossomed into a Pro Bowl performer who grew quite (and sometimes unpredictably) cogent. It did not matter that a comparative series of quarterback charlatans (Quincy Carter, Anthony Wright, Ryan Leaf, Clint Stoerner, and Chad Hutchinson), a sturdy journeyman (Vinny Testaverde) who played the temporary fill-in, a celebrated two-sport college star (Drew Henson) who did not get far with a pro translation that was pure stagnation, and a former Patriot-turned-Buffalo Bill (Drew Bledsoe) that was both a purposely poor listener and nearly over the hill . . . all followed three-time Super Bowl Champion and Hall of Famer, Troy Aikman, before Romo was even given a chance to be the Cowboys’ offensive lion tamer.

The standards of success established long ago by two-time Super Bowl Champion and Hall of Famer, Roger Staubach, irreversibly spoiled Cowboys Nation and forcibly required Danny White to talk the talk and walk the walk. White – in the prime of his career – had the added benefit of a relatively-loaded, veteran-laden offense (Tony Dorsett, Timmy Newsome, Tony Hill, Mike Renfro, Doug Cosbie, and Tom Rafferty towing the line) and an equally-aging-yet-still-FLEXible defense (Ed "Too Tall" Jones, John Dutton, Randy "Manster" White, Jim Jeffcoat, Eugene "Hittin' Machine" Lockhart, Everson Walls, Ron Fellows, Bill Bates, and Michael Downs) that forced opponents (more often than not) to submit.

Even when White enjoyed play-call and roster weaknesses of few-to-no, Daring Danny still managed to incite the famously stoic Tom Landry into infamously yelling: "No, Danny! NO!" And a forceful fishy claim decades later – towards the end of a certain Seattle playoff game deflator – may, May, MAY have also bubbled up from the Big Tuna about Romo.

Both Danny White and Tony Romo had to keep their head on a swivel due to untimely pass protection drivel. White had Phil "Holding Number 75" Pozderac, and Romo had Doug (Feel) Free (to run right by me and blast my QB). While Free did have his productive streaks, he also  – on occasion – had referees scrambling for a last rites cleric.

 
 
 
 
 
 
Romo rarely enjoyed the consistent health, skill, and play execution of the offensive lines and determined defenses with whom Aikman (and White) played through much of his prime. Comparing Aikman to Romo – who played for much of his career within Norvel’s no longer novel system and surrounded with an inconsistently-stocked roster – either exposes Tony as a big game imposter or the unfortunate victim of a perpetually unfair crime. The terrific or terrible truth lies somewhere in the middle of the gridiron griddle.

Romo – like White – was, again, hardly held blameless in his teams’ postseason blight, even on occasions where Tony did many team-uplifting things right.

 
 
During each of the Cowboys’ three consecutive 8-8 seasons, there were season-extending moments – in the presence of bumps and bruises but in the clear absence of a reasonably-loaded team – when only Tony’s IMPROVISATIONAL MAGIC SHOW could bridge the gap, between NFC East division winners and drawing straws to take the wrap. The fate-outfoxing opportunities were there, the play calls (from a creatively constricted coordinator) seemed acceptably right, but the IN THE MOMENT execution was repeatedly, mind-numbingly shite. It was only later in Romo’s career (with a steadily-improving offensive line to dampen impulsive oversteer) that he finally rounded out his mental maturity and became a truly complete veteran QB. Just when Tony needed one final magic spell to escape his own injury-driven mortality, Harry Romo, err, Tony Houdini came up empty.

Will He Or Won’t He?

If Romo and TV commentating get along well, he may finally be able to tell his lingering what-ifs to go to hell. If Tony determines the booth experience is too taxing – and straight up retirement appears too relaxing – would he dare entertain a return to the field with a body that (while well-rested) is no longer maxing? Romo – lest any fan or prognosticator forget – merely quit the NFL and yet, he also knows without another similarly great-and-protective wall, he could unwisely suffer a deeply permanent fall.

 
 
Romo (ridiculously?) has not yet turned in his paperwork to the league office to officially retire. He most certainly still has the playing desire, competitive fire, and game day services to sell (to a contending team with an offensive line shockingly capable of protecting him from more injury hell). The Tortured Cowboys Fan hopes, however, that Tony sees his playing career truth, potentially prognosticates like the announcing greats, and hits it out of the booth. The SIX MILLION, err, 108 MILLION DOLLAR MAN would also appear to be saddling the Dallas Cowboys with a dead money cap hit that triggers “some” fans to abuse something stronger than Vermouth.

Will Romo give himself a robust chance to become a righteous regular on many a game day broadcast or give into the dangerous urge to put his brittle body back on game day blast? Will Tony determine (like not so many other equally-intense NFL competitors before him, who chose to stop before things got seriously dim) that he has, indeed, rung his last helmet-wearing bell and begrudgingly accept that there are no further grid iron demons he can realistically return to quell?

We shall see. We always do.