Home History Blogs Portfolio FAQ Contact Terms Of Use
 
2008  2009  2010  2011  2012  2013  2014  2015  2016  2017
2018  2019  2020  2021  2022  2023  2024  2025  2026  2027
2028  2029  2030  2031  2032  2033  2034  2035  2036  2037
 
 
 
2019-2020 Offseason: Who Might The Cowboys Aspire To Hire? Part II: From Mentally-Rested To Extremely Battle-Tested
 
 
 
This edition of "The Tortured Cowboys Fan" has also been published by the fine folks at Sports TalkLine.
 
 
 
January 4, 2020 At 9:00 PM CST
By Eric M. Scharf
 
The seemingly immortal 76-year-old Mick Jagger has often sung "Time is on my side, yes, it is." But – when it comes to the 77-year-old owner, president, and general manager of “America’s Team” – that theme quickly loses its fizz.

“I don’t have time to have a bad time, it’s not on my schedule. Each year does create more urgency." – Jerry Jones on 105.3 The Fan exactly one year ago on 01-04-2019 (referring to how the Dallas Cowboys’ playoff success – since their last Super Bowl – has looked oh so lean).

GM Jerry and VP Stephen – after practically 25 years of intermittent cheers mixed with decades of jeers and tears – have another rare shot at bringing the Cowboys’ on-the-field fortunes (at least?) back to even.

The arms on Jerry’s internal clock – again and again and again – are spinning. He (and a great majority of “Cowboys Nation”) are desperate to avoid another round of “tear it down and go back to the beginning.”

 
While there is a boldness in going with the infectious energy (and often creativity and flexibility) of youth, sometimes one still must ponder the long-standing wisdom of those viewed (however inaccurately) as too set in their ways or a bit long in the tooth. So, who in the vein of “Gandalf the Grey” can be most wizard-like towards the Cowboys performing the right way?

Mike McCarthy
 
 
The former head coach of the Green Bay Packers – who partnered with Aaron “Bad Man” Rodgers to deliver Super Bowl XLV victory – certainly has his backers, but something about this offensively-charged individual (loosely?) suggests another “Yes Man” (Jason Garrett or – GASP – Wade Phillips) trajectory. The 56-year-old (to his great credit even with the burning desire to offer a corrective edit) has historically shown the valuable ability to simply focus on coaching (even with painfully-public, past complaints from Rodgers or the massive ego of Jerry Jones – possibly – approaching).

Then, again, fans who (naturally and understandably) gravitate towards the more moxie-mouthed, bend-the-knee-to-no-one Sean Payton, might be surprised to see how little daylight appears between their records (before they start hatin’ and humiliatin’). Payton’s (Drew Brees-powered) overall 130-77 record includes a .628 winning percentage, six division titles, a 8-6 postseason mark, three NFC title games, and one Super Bowl ring. McCarthy’s (Brett Favre / Aaron-Rodgers-powered) overall 125-77-2 record includes a .618 winning percentage, six division titles, a 10-8 playoff mark, four NFC title games, and one Super Bowl ring. The critical questions beg for Dallas: Did McCarthy – more often than not – scheme Aaron Rodgers into position for the most successful scoring shot? Can McCarthy (in the permanent absence of his system-memorized, implicitly-trusted, freelance-enabled, Super Bowl-winning, two-time NFL MVP) be creative enough with (a comparatively, functionally-rigid) Dak Prescott to get in position for the Cowboys’ sixth Super Bowl chalice? If his scheduled interview with Dallas is any indicator, the team (his Packers had a painful penchant for beating) appears to be an admirer that holds no malice.

Leslie Frazier
 
 
Should the long-time, secondary-centric defensive specialist (as well as former Vikings head coach and current Buffalo Bills defensive coordinator) be granted another opportunity to lead a team? Yes, absolutely, and Dallas should be involved (for a coach who might see their problems solved), but it may only be to fulfill the NFL's mandatory Rooney Rule theme. Still, GM Jerry got to see up close and personal – on a Thanksgiving Day so horrible – how the 60-year-old was able to make the Cowboys’ “top yardage-gaining offense” look like it was still performing a pre-game rehearsal. While his defense made a few critical errors against the Houston Texans in the Bills’ wild card playoff game, his unit cannot be judged for Josh Allen’s Jekyll and Hyde performance so disappointingly lame.

Mike Zimmer
 
 
While former Cowboys head coach Bill Parcells regularly receives the most credit for triggering 63-year-old Mike Zimmer's maximum effectiveness (as a defensive coordinator during his time under Parcells from 2003-2006), the current Minnesota Vikings head coach actually begin his "Tour de Dallas" as an assistant coach of nickel defense under Barry Switzer in 1994. As was the reason for his selection to lead the Vikings, there remains much quality coaching history to most people's liking. He paid his collegiate dues through defensive assignments with Missouri, Weber State, and Washington State before – again – landing with Dallas to help them win the Super Bowl XXX chalice. More impressive may have been his ability (perhaps through invaluable capability) to survive multiple changes at head coach (from Barry Switzer to Chan Gailey to Dave Campo to Parcells).
 
 
"Zim" went on to the Atlanta Falcons and Cincinnati Bengals for a couple more defensive coordinator spells before getting his shot within the NFC North division as a head-coaching candidate so hot. While he missed out on Brett Favre-quality quarterbacking, his defenses have kept the Vikings (at least) in the postseason picture (during his five years and through his current 58-39-1 record) even with offenses typically lacking . . . an inconsistent Kirk Cousins notwithstanding.

Within an organization that has shown a fondness for familiar faces (especially those unwilling to discourage GM Jerry from encroaching on coaching spaces), Zimmer's more-than-reasonable success (as well-rounded defensive expert preferring a run-first offense) would certainly make for a desirable leadership and motivational presence. The Tortured Cowboys Fan makes zero effort to hide tremendous affection for the coach (who may find himself available following another postseason failure so assailable) who could, should, and would be given a chance to indulge in some serious Cowboys correction.

"We value Mike and Rick’s leadership, and we have every intent of Mike continuing as the head coach of the Minnesota Vikings and Rick leading our football operations, next year and beyond.” - Mark Wilf, President and co-owner of the Minnesota Vikings (with – perhaps – a “kiss of death” statement that may not hold up with another postseason result not to the Wilf family’s liking).

Urban Meyer
 
 
The current assistant athletic director and former head football coach of THE Ohio State University has demonstrated – wherever he has gone – an incredible winning propensity. The 55-year-old college football juggernaut has amassed a 187-32 record (including multiple national championships, oodles of conference and division crowns, and a pile of personal plaudits), a treasure chest of NCAA achievements among the best. While Meyer (from all publicly-shared indications) seems set for life, he has a well-documented ego that (regardless of his intermittent health issues) still occasionally twists the what-if knife. If there is one job that could coax Urban Meyer out of retirement, it would apparently be something critical to the success of improving the Cowboys’ current, Super Bowl-starved environment.

 
“That’s the one. That's the New York Yankees. That's the Dallas Cowboys. That's THE one. Great city. You got Dak Prescott. You got Zeke Elliott. You got loaded team. And I can’t speak for him (Oklahoma head coach Lincoln Riley) obviously, I hate to even speculate because I don’t know him, that’s really not fair, but to me, that’s the one job in professional football that you say, ‘I got to go do that,” Meyer said. “Absolutely. Absolutely. That one? Yes.” - Urban Meyer (who – as a guest on Colin Cowherd's "The Herd" FOX Sports talk show on October 18, 2019 – practically threw Jason Garrett on a funeral pyre).

“For Urban Meyer to say that is a compliment. Period. I really know that. The job is a great job. Now, that’s not implying that I made it that way, or I don’t make it that way. It’s just the place to be.” – GM Jerry on 105.3 The Fan (making no effort to diminish the position to which so many coaches publicly and privately aspire).

 
The 55-year-old Meyer commands Big Tuna-esque motivational skills that have spurred team after team towards substantial game day thrills. He has a considerable network of capable, willing, potential staff members (to “discourage” GM Jerry from suggesting any low-heat embers). Meyer, in fact, may be in the best position of all possible candidates to establish a staff that includes one or more key, understudy dudes. Cowboys Nation may recall how – had Parcells not decided to retire following Tony Romo’s butterfingers so dire – assistant head coach Sean Payton would (not might) have been convinced to remain in place to receive that head-coaching torch with plenty of determination, energy, and fire.

Meyer (according to “sources”) would welcome the competitive challenge, but he does not NEED it, and he would have no problem professionally telling GM Jerry to shove it. Meyer (according to every talking head imaginable) has an ego so incredible, which is a worst-kept secret so hysterical. And yet, AND YET, just like Bill Parcells before him, it may be THAT ego driving his (privately-held?) belief that (no matter Jerry’s incredulous moan) HE ALONE can resurrect the Cowboys of old, making a working relationship with GM Jerry more bearable. The Thanos-like recognition that would come with having snapped away years of morbid failure would be a story to behold and infinitely retold.

 
Meyer can continue comfortably (but not competitively) collecting analyst paychecks from Fox . . . or GM Jerry can (swallow familiarly hard and) offer Urban the chance to become the Cowboys’ version of Walter White: “I am the danger, the one who knocks.”

Will They Or Won’t They?

“I was talking to (former Dallas Cowboys’ tight end) Martellus (“Brother Of Michael”) Bennett before the game and I said, ‘of all the places you’ve played, where did you enjoy playing the most?’ [Bennett] said, ‘I loved playing at New England.’ I said, ‘because you won?’ He said, ’Winning was great but I love that everything we did was JUST ABOUT FOOTBALL.’ Amazing, right? That’s the business we are in, but sometimes I don’t know that football takes priority with the Cowboys and I think as a result SOMETIMES the product suffers.’” – Troy Aikman.

 
GM Jerry has a truly fascinating decision to make. It is far, FAR less about whether the embarrassing check he cuts (to eradicate his team’s competitive stank) will truly break the bank. It remains exactly about how much his ego can take. Will he set aside his mirrored-sunglasses and allow a larger-than-Jerry figure to put out years of incompetence fires . . . or will he bring in another yes-man to fail until (like the dearly departed Davis) he physically expires? WHO will be allowed by an ego so proud?

We shall see. We always do.